Twice in my life I have grappled with the ambition of creating an opera. I just do not have the yeoman time in a performing company, or the music theory classes, to pull it off. But the stuff I hear in my head finds its way out through the piano occasionally.
One of them is a redaction of the Fourth Branch of the Welsh national epic The Mabinogion. The other is a life of my high-school English teacher.
Martha Alexander D. was about the same age I am now when I met her. I look back and wonder about generational changes, or growing up in the Depression, or cigarettes and bourbon: her face was already lined and she had her graying hair expertly color-rinsed, but you still knew somehow it was gray under there. She had the nodal, purring Tallulah voice that a pack a day gives people, and astonishingly shapely legs that were once the topic of anonymous harassing calls from a student at two in the morning.
She was that vanishing American archetype, the classically educated, bourbon-soaked Southern aristocrat — William Faulkner in a skirt suit from Talbots or Britches of Georgetown. She lived in a bungalow in the neighboring city of Falls Church, which seemed to be populated by retired, boozy women lawyers and similar professionals, prone to knocking at the back door to borrow a cup of Virginia Gentleman. There was a black cat, and later a ginger-white tom who turned out to be a Turkish Van — I helped her rescue him from neglectful owners who hadn’t even had him neutered.
I took her literature class my last year of high school, wrote to her all through college, and came back to visit her on the holidays. I was hardly unique in that — she inspired loyalty in her old students. We all appreciated being treated like adults, probably — I think now — because she couldn’t be bothered to adopt a custodial mode.
She was solidly ahead of her time on most things, and was once heard thundering at the high school principal after a colleague was sacked over being caught at a gay pickup venue: “If we fire everyone on this faculty who’s homosexual, there might be you and me left!!!!”
I only realized in retrospect that she was, as time went on, sinking not just into the bourbon bottle but into some dream of her past, recreated periodically as she saw fit. By the time I was a year or two out of college I had heard several versions of some episodes of her life, though the particulars remained fairly constant. She was the oldest of three daughters — “The commonest family constellation in the world, my dear, and the most mythic one, like Cinderella’s.” Her mother had been twitted over and over on her dark hair and complexion: “Where did you get that little gypsy girl?” Her grandmother had a generous estate, and in the garden there were white peacocks and ordinary peacocks. And then the 1929 crash came and her father had to take paying work, at the University, and there she hobnobbed with members of the literature faculty, one of whom took her to black speakeasies to hear the jazz musicians and deflowered her on a country lane – first reciting John Donne under the stars, then bluntly ordering her to take her clothes off. It sounded like date rape to me. But I have a damnable weakness for Donne, myself.
She married and later divorced an Irish divil who wrote speeches for the US State Department and regularly furgled celebrity women, preferably black. They had one son after she lost a pregnancy that would have been a daughter, almost dying herself in the process. If she got far enough into the bourbon she would recall the “white peace” that settled on her when she almost bled out during the miscarriage. “I am not afraid of dying,” she would say, with a slight edge of bathos. “Any time will be suitable. I am ready.”
Her bungalow was filled with curiosities — a ceramic dragon made by a student, a bird sculpted of the largest single piece of red amber ever recorded, a plaster statue of the Buddha whose topknot had been mercilessly chewed by the cats, an amethyst heart big enough to fill your palm and weight down your hand. She collected mermaid artifacts of all descriptions; the only photograph I have of her involves one. She kept jugs of horrendous Gallo wine in the pantry. I still make her recipe of spinach noodles tossed with sour cream and red caviare — not often, but I make it.
One night, loaded to the gills, she pulled down a book and read aloud Conrad Aiken’s entire Letter from Li Po, the encomium of a drunken poet by a drunken poet. It was like Von Neumann’s Catastrophe of the Infinite Regress.
Li Po, brought drunk to court, took up his brush,
but washed his face among the lilies first,
then wrote the song of Lady Flying Swallow:
which Hsuang Sung, the emperor, forthwith played,
moving quick fingers on a flute of jade.
Who will forget that afternoon?
The night I told her I was worried, that the five o’clock drink had become the eleven a.m. eye-opener and where was it going from there?, she told me she would send me home in a cab — I usually poached a ride from a friend who worked a late shift — and we never spoke again.
The opening bars of the prelude I wrote shift chords through five keys. There’s a dainty waltz for the plantation reminiscences, and a hammering F-minor setting of Donne’s Lecture Upon The Shadow.
Love is growing, or full constant light,
And his first minute, after Noone, is Night.
She died the year after I married, of some cancer or other, as recorded in the death notices of the Washington Post. Tough old bird. Her liver must have been made out of old Army boots.
I hope that she wasn’t kidding us all, and that she wasn’t afraid.

It must be the year of the Mermaid!
She sounds sensible to me and therefore wouldn’t fear dying – it would be a complete waste of time and energy …….
[ooo - just noticed 'possible related posts - Flanders and Swann ....... whooooooosh]
Your fault for putting up that mermaid picture.
It left my mind running on this, which I’d been meaning to write.
I am left wanting to read more! Is there more? Will there be more?
that’s beautiful sledpress, really beautiful
Thank you, Nursie. Az, after thirty years it will take a while for things to float up to the surface, but I probably have a whole mental snapshot album, if I made a pot of tea and sat down to think… I still remember her always using chopsticks to winkle the cat food out of the can, or that whisky-voice calling the Turkish Van, with a mixture of indulgence and condescension, “Man Cat!”
Another character in a book. This could get me in pots of trouble.
Why would it get you in trouble? didn’t you say she was dead now?
I truly love this post, it is filled with wonderful images and great nostalgia. I am envious that you had a chance to actually know a great teacher that you admired; the one I remember and would have liked to have known was the spanish teacher at our school, Mrs. Langley. But the teachers at our school uniformly kept their distance from the student body, we were not allowed to be close. How sad.
You know, you could just start writing the operas without the music theory lessons.
Well, there is that surviving son.
I do have stacks of scribbled stave paper, but kind of ran into a wall because until you have really rolled around in an art form at the pragmatic level — what works? what will the instruments tolerate? How do singers interpret what’s on the page? — you not only are likely to fuck up, but ideas don’t flow as easily. Our current civilization brutally under-rates experience and drill. I need a couple of extra lifetimes.
I hum the prominent bits that came to me when the idea for the biographical opera was really rolling; the Donne setting is independently playable. I have a whole libretto for the Mabinogion piece, but I suspect it sucks.
Maybe you could write it as fiction, based on memories of Martha?
It was best as a sort of Bomarzo -like succession of scenes — reflecting the snapshots and mental video-clips that she favored us with when she’d had a bit to drink (her “bit” would probably have felled two Russian Army corporals). The first act in the prewar South, the second revolving around her marriage and the third when she was the grande dame of Falls Church, a strange and lovable melange of snobbery, bathos, brilliance and resignation.
Nothing teaches you music theory quicker than just forging ahead and composing. I wrote an entire piano/vocal score for a musical version of the film The Hudsucker Proxy despite getting a D in Theory II at the conservatoire . The project was merely for my own amusement, but it really taught me a lot about how music works … more than the freaking theory classes ever did.
Now I am going to have to go look up that film; the title is truly alarming.
Love The Hudsucker Proxy and trying to imagine it as a musical. Though I quite like the music used in this scene…
I have a feeling you would love the film. It’s a marvelous parody-tribute to Preston Sturges, “The Sweet Smell of Success,” and oh so much more.
OMG. That takes me back to the first film I remember even halfway understanding — probably one of the things that warped me for life — IAL Diamond’s “1,2,3″ with Jimmy Cagney as the Coca-Cola mogul of West Berlin. They used the same Khachaturian “Sabre Dance” in the seedy cabaret scene; I suspect an hommage.